The Other Parent Won’t Reply. How Do You Make Parenting Decisions?

Where Life Meets the Law | Divorce & Family Law

The Short Answer

Start with the parenting plan or allocation judgment. In Illinois, a parent’s silence does not, by itself, transfer significant decision-making authority to the other parent. The order may already give you authority over the issue, require joint decisions, or provide a process for resolving disagreement. Ordinary decisions during your parenting time are not necessarily the same as major decisions about schooling or health care. If nonresponse repeatedly prevents required decisions, document it and consider whether you need enforcement, a clearer plan, or modification. The correct request depends on the order and the child’s circumstances. 750 ILCS 5/600(e), (k); 750 ILCS 5/602.5(a)–(c); 750 ILCS 5/610.5(a), (c)–(e).

The Human Story

The following is a fictional illustration, not an actual client story.

School needs a response about your child’s next-year placement. A specialist recommends a follow-up appointment. You send the other parent the information, then a reminder. Both messages go unanswered.

You cannot postpone every decision. But you also worry that acting without a response will be portrayed as excluding the other parent. When the next exchange arrives, you want to focus on your child rather than argue about unread messages.

Silence can mean many things. A parent may have missed a message, may need more information, may disagree, or may be avoiding the conversation. You cannot safely draw a legal conclusion from any one explanation without looking at the order and the pattern of communication.

What you can do is separate the questions. Is this a decision the order gives you alone? Is it a significant issue assigned jointly? Does the plan say when a response is due or how a dispute is resolved? Is there an immediate safety problem, or a decision that can wait for the required process?

Those distinctions help you respond to the actual problem instead of treating every unanswered message as a new custody dispute.

What Illinois Law Says

Significant decisions and daily care are different

The court allocates significant decision-making responsibilities according to the child’s best interests, issue by issue. Statutory subjects include education, health, religion—with special limits on how religious upbringing is allocated—and extracurricular activities. One parent, both parents, or neither parent may receive a particular allocation as the statute and order permit. 750 ILCS 5/602.5(a)–(c).

Parenting time generally carries responsibility for caretaking functions and nonsignificant decisions during that time. Read the actual plan before assuming that every appointment, school communication, or activity requires joint consent—or that none does. 750 ILCS 5/600(e), (f), (k).

Illinois requires parenting plans to address decision-making and an enforceable parenting-time schedule or method, along with other implementation matters. Where relevant, clear communication and dispute-resolution provisions can make an order usable when cooperation weakens. 750 ILCS 5/602.10(f).

Enforcing an order is different from changing one

If the other parent is not following a specific requirement, identify that requirement and the dated conduct. Illinois provides an expedited petition process for abuse of allocated parenting time; its pleading and remedies are tied to that subject and should not be assumed to cover every significant-decision deadlock. 750 ILCS 5/607.5(a)–(d).

If the allocation itself no longer works, modification has different standards. A motion to change significant decision-making ordinarily cannot be made within two years of the order, subject to statutory exceptions—including stipulation, specified restrictions, or court permission based on affidavits showing reason to believe the present environment may cause the serious harm described in the statute. Parenting time has a different timing rule. Modification generally requires the specified change in circumstances and the child’s best interests, with additional statutory exceptions. 750 ILCS 5/610.5(a), (c)–(e).

A parenting coordinator is not a substitute judge for major allocations. Illinois’s coordination rule addresses implementation disputes but does not authorize a coordinator to recommend an allocation of significant decision-making responsibility. Illinois Supreme Court Rule 909(b), (g).

What Changes the Answer?

The order’s wording. Sole authority over education is different from joint authority with a dispute process. A general expectation of communication may be harder to apply than a specific deadline and method.

The decision’s urgency. A routine choice, a time-sensitive medical issue, and a long-term treatment decision do not present the same practical problem. Do not use a claimed emergency to bypass an order when the facts do not support it.

The pattern. One missed message is different from months of nonresponse after clear, timely requests. A dated record helps establish what information was provided and whether a response was possible.

Safety. If intimidation or violence affects communication, consider whether the plan’s information-sharing provisions or a court process needs a safety adjustment. Illinois allows specified personal-information provisions in a parenting plan to be omitted in abuse or best-interests circumstances. 750 ILCS 5/602.10(f).

What You Need to Know Before You Act

Keep communications child-focused and usable as a record. State the decision, share the relevant information, identify any genuine deadline, and ask for a response through the channel the order requires. Avoid sending repeated accusations in place of the information needed to decide.

Then identify the relief you actually need. An order clarifying who decides if a response does not arrive may solve a recurring problem more effectively than arguing about one missed text. If you seek to change a recent decision-making allocation, the two-year filing restriction and its exceptions deserve attention before you file. 750 ILCS 5/610.5(a).

Do not quietly rewrite the parenting schedule by habit. Even where parents have developed a different arrangement, the statutory route for recognizing it has specific conditions, including an exception where apparent acquiescence did not reflect meaningful consent. 750 ILCS 5/610.5(e)(1).

The Path Forward

Keep a neutral communications log recording the date, the decision needed, information supplied, response deadline, reply, and effect on the child. Keep the order, relevant school or medical information, and complete messages—not just selected screenshots.

If your parenting plan does not provide a workable decision-making process, you may request a family-law consultation with Joerika Stitt Esquire, LLC to discuss the existing order and whether clarification, enforcement, or modification may be appropriate.

Educational information only. This article does not constitute legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws, program standards, and deadlines can change; the outcome depends on the applicable facts and law.

Previous
Previous

You Agree on Everything. Why Would You Need a Lawyer?

Next
Next

You’re Ready to Settle. Your Spouse Isn’t. Is Mediation Still an Option?